| INDIANA HIGH SCHOOL FOOTBALL STATE FINALS HISTORY | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Class 5A | ||||||||
| Year | Champion | Runner-up | Score | Winning coach | W-L | Runner-up coach | W-L | Location |
| 1985 | Warren Central | Valparaiso | 41- 7 | Jerry Stauffer | 14-0 | Mark Hoffman | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1986 | Carmel | Fort Wayne Snider | 20-17† | Jim Belden | 14-0 | Mike Hawley | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1987 | Ben Davis | Highland | 14- 7 | Dick Dullaghan | 12-2 | Dave Shelbourne | 9-5 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1988 | Ben Davis | Marion | 43- 0 | Dick Dullaghan | 14-0 | Mark Surface | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1989 | Carmel | Penn | 10- 7 | Jim Belden | 13-1 | Chris Geesman | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1990 | Ben Davis | Marion | 37- 3 | Dick Dullaghan | 13-1 | Mark Surface | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1991 | Ben Davis | Penn | 38-14 | Dick Dullaghan | 14-0 | Chris Geesman | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1992 | Fort Wayne Snider | Ben Davis | 24-21 | Russ Isaacs | 14-0 | Dick Dullaghan | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1993 | Bloomington South | Lake Central | 33-27 | Mo Moriarity | 14-0 | Elmer Britton | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1994 | Castle | Portage | 30-12 | John Lidy | 12-2 | Craig Buzea | 13-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1995 | Penn | Evansville North | 35-13 | Chris Geesman | 14-0 | Mike Wilson | 13-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1996 | Penn | Ben Davis | 17-14 | Chris Geesman | 13-1 | Dick Dullaghan | 12-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1997 | Penn | Bloomington South | 21-20 | Chris Geesman | 14-1 | Mo Moriarity | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1998 | Bloomington South | Homestead | 35-14 | Mo Moriarity | 14-0 | Cary Cavacini | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1999 | Ben Davis | Penn | 27- 3 | Dick Dullaghan | 15-0 | Chris Geesman | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2000 | Penn | Center Grove | 21- 0 | Chris Geesman | 14-1 | Eric Moore | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2001 | Ben Davis | Valparaiso | 35-16 | Dick Dullaghan | 15-0 | Mark Hoffman | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2002 | Ben Davis | Fort Wayne Snider | 31- 7 | Dick Dullaghan | 12-3 | Russ Isaacs | 13-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2003 | Warren Central | Penn | 57- 7 | Kevin Wright | 13-2 | Cory Yeoman | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2004 | Warren Central | Fort Wayne Snider | 35-23 | Kevin Wright | 14-1 | Russ Isaacs | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2005 | Warren Central | Hamilton Southeastern | 55-20 | Kevin Wright | 14-1 | Rob Cutter | 11-4 | RCA Dome |
| 2006 | Warren Central | Carmel | 35-14 | Steve Tutsie | 15-0 | Mo Moriarity | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2007 | Carmel | Pike | 16- 7 | Mo Moriarity | 13-2 | Derek Moyers | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2008 | Center Grove | Carmel | 36-33 | Eric Moore | 14-1 | Mo Moriarity | 13-2 | Lucas Oil Stadium |
| Class 4A | ||||||||
| Year | Champion | Runner-up | Score | Winning coach | W-L | Runner-up coach | W-L | Location |
| 1983 | Penn | Indianapolis Washington | 25-14 | Chris Geesman | 14-0 | Bob Springer | 13-1 | North Central |
| 1984 | Warren Central | Hobart | 28- 8 | Jerry Staufer | 14-0 | Don Howell | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1985 | Brownsburg | Hobart | 23-17 | Mike Godan | 14-0 | Don Howell | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1986 | DeKalb | Franklin Central | 28- 7 | Dale Hummer | 13-1 | Chuck Stephens | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1987 | Hobart | Jasper | 31- 0 | Don Howell | 14-0 | Jerry Brewer | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1988 | Goshen | Franklin Central | 24-10 | Randy Robertson | 14-0 | Chuck Stephens | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1989 | Hobart | Franklin Central | 17- 7 | Don Howell | 13-1 | Chuck Stephens | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1990 | Franklin Central | Hobart | 34-14 | Chuck Stephens | 14-0 | Don Howell | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1991 | Hobart | Seymour | 20- 0 | Don Howell | 13-1 | Joe Goodman | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1992 | Harrison (West Lafayette) | Fort Wayne Wayne | 21- 3 | A.J. Rickard | 13-1 | Mark Newlin | 10-4 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1993 | Hobart | East Central | 31-18 | Don Howell | 13-1 | Rod Ballart | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1994 | East Central | DeKalb | 35- 0 | Rod Ballart | 14-0 | Ron Kock | 13-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1995 | Fort Wayne Wayne | Franklin County | 28- 8 | Mark Newlin | 12-2 | Kent Grider | 12-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1996 | Indianapolis Cathedral | Hobart | 27- 7 | Rick Streiff | 14-0 | Don Howell | 12-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1997 | Griffith | Hamilton Southeastern | 49- 7 | Russ Radtke | 14-1 | Rob Cutter | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1998 | Indianapolis Cathedral | Concord | 38- 7 | Rick Streiff | 13-2 | Tim Dawson | 10-5 | RCA Dome |
| 1999 | Indianapolis Cathedral | Goshen | 24-21 | Rick Streiff | 13-2 | Brad Park | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2000 | East Noble | Plainfield | 28- 7 | Tim Able | 14-1 | Chuck Schwanekamp | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2001 | Jasper | Delta | 35-20 | Jerry Brewer | 13-1 | Grant Zgunda | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2002 | Indianapolis Roncalli | Fort Wayne Dwenger | 24-21 | Bruce Scifres | 10-4 | Chris Svarczkopf | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2003 | Indianapolis Roncalli | East Noble | 17- 0 | Bruce Scifres | 12-3 | Chris DePew | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2004 | Indianapolis Roncalli | Wawasee | 25-10 | Bruce Scifres | 13-2 | Joe Rietveld | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2005 | Lowell | Indianapolis Roncalli | 28-27 | Kirk Kennedy | 11-4 | Bruce Scifres | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2006 | Indianapolis Cathedral | Concord | 38-14 | Jim O’Hara | 13-2 | Tim Dawson | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2007 | Evansville Reitz | Lowell | 33-14 | John Hart | 15-0 | Kirk Kennedy | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2008 | Indianapolis Cathedral | Fort Wayne Dwenger | 10- 7 | Rick Streiff | 12-2 | Chris Svarczkopf | 14-1 | Lucas Oil Stadium |
| Class 3A | ||||||||
| Year | Champion | Runner-up | Score | Winning coach | W-L | Runner-up coach | W-L | Location |
| 1973 | South Bend Washington | Indianapolis Cathedral | 19-13 | Bob Van Camp | 12-0 | Mike McGinley | 11-1 | South Bend |
| 1974 | Indianapolis Washington | Mishawaka | 19-12 | Bob Springer | 12-0 | Bill Doba | 10-2 | North Central |
| 1975 | Valparaiso | Carmel | 14-13 | Tom Stokes | 12-0 | Dick Dullaghan | 11-1 | Valparaiso |
| 1976 | Merrillville | Indianapolis Cathedral | 28-24 | Ken Haupt | 11-1 | Mike McGinley | 12-1 | Cathedral |
| 1977 | Portage | Evansville Reitz | 33-14 | Les Klein | 12-1 | Bob Padgett | 12-1 | North Central |
| 1978 | Carmel | Fort Wayne Dwenger | 35-18 | Dick Dullaghan | 13-0 | Larry Bartolameolli | 12-1 | North Central |
| 1979 | Columbus East | Hobart | 21-14 | John Stafford | 13-0 | Don Howell | 11-1 | North Central |
| 1980 | Carmel | Hobart | 13- 7 | Jim Belden | 13-0 | Don Howell | 11-2 | North Central |
| 1981 | Carmel | Fort Wayne Snider | 27- 0 | Jim Belden | 14-0 | Mike Hawley | 13-1 | North Central |
| 1982 | Castle | Hobart | 26-23 | John Lidy | 14-0 | Don Howell | 13-1 | North Central |
| 1983 | Fort Wayne Dwenger | Indianapolis Roncalli | 22-21 | Andy Johns | 14-0 | Bill Kuntz | 12-2 | Warren Central |
| 1984 | Brownsburg | Concord | 17-12 | Mike Godan | 14-0 | Tom Conn | 10-4 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1985 | Indianapolis Roncalli | Wawasee | 37- 3 | Bill Kuntz | 13-1 | Myron Dickerson | 9-5 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1986 | Indianapolis Cathedral | NorthWood | 12- 0 | Mike McGinley | 12-2 | Jim Andrews | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1987 | Zionsville | Elwood | 23- 7 | Rick Wimmer | 14-0 | Mark Hughes | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1988 | Indianapolis Roncalli | Tipton | 14-13 | Bill Sylvester | 12-2 | Mike Tolle | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1989 | Hammond Noll | Indianapolis Roncalli | 20-14 | Jerry Vlasic | 13-1 | Bill Sylvester | 10-4 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1990 | Fort Wayne Dwenger | New Palestine | 56-14 | Andy Johns | 14-0 | Marvin Shepler | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1991 | Fort Wayne Dwenger | Indianapolis Cathedral | 34-27 | Andy Johns | 13-1 | Rick Streiff | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1992 | Indianapolis Cathedral | Northwestern | 33-14 | Rick Streiff | 12-2 | Dan Robinson | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1993 | Indianapolis Roncalli | NorthWood | 14-12 | Bruce Scifres | 14-0 | Rich Dodson | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1994 | Indianapolis Roncalli | Tipton | 35-14 | Bruce Scifres | 12-2 | Mike Tolle | 12-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1995 | South Bend St. Joseph’s | Jasper | 28- 0 | Frank Amato | 14-0 | Jerry Brewer | 13-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1996 | Zionsville | Fort Wayne Dwenger | 14- 7 | Larry McWhorter | 14-0 | Andy Johns | 12-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1997 | Indianapolis Chatard | Andrean | 27-24 | Craig Barr | 14-1 | Ted Karras Jr. | 12-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1998 | Indianapolis Chatard | NorthWood | 23- 6 | Craig Barr | 13-2 | Rich Dodson | 11-4 | RCA Dome |
| 1999 | Indianapolis Roncalli | Norwell | 24-14 | Bruce Scifres | 15-0 | Gary Scott | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2000 | Heritage Hills | Zionsville | 27-24† | Bob Clayton | 15-0 | Larry McWhorter | 11-4 | RCA Dome |
| 2001 | Indianapolis Chatard | Andrean | 3- 0 | Tom Dilley | 11-4 | Jeff Karras | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2002 | Indianapolis Chatard | Andrean | 31-12 | Tom Dilley | 15-0 | Wally McCormack | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2003 | Indianapolis Chatard | NorthWood | 49- 0 | Vince Lorenzano | 14-1 | Rich Dodson | 11-4 | RCA Dome |
| 2004 | Andrean | Heritage Hills | 21-14 | Brett St. Germain | 13-2 | Bob Clayton | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2005 | NorthWood | Indianapolis Chatard | 7- 0 | Rich Dodson | 9-6 | Vince Lorenzano | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2006 | Indianapolis Chatard | Norwell | 7- 0 | Vince Lorenzano | 14-1 | Jeff Miller | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2007 | Indianapolis Chatard | South Bend St. Joseph’s | 31- 7 | Vince Lorenzano | 12-3 | Kevin Downey | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2008 | Bellmont | Evansville Memorial | 28-14 | Toney Bergman | 14-1 | John Hurley | 12-3 | Lucas Oil Stadium |
| Class 2A | ||||||||
| Year | Champion | Runner-up | Score | Winning coach | W-L | Runner-up coach | W-L | Location |
| 1973 | Greenfield-Central | Blackford | 21-12 | Clayton Myers | 12-0 | Eldon Leeth | 9-3 | Greenfield |
| 1974 | Blackford | Boonville | 28-14 | Eldon Leeth | 12-0 | Bill Harrawood | 10-2 | Blackford |
| 1975 | Mishawaka Marian | Greenfield-Central | 34- 0 | Mike Hecklinski | 11-0 | Clayton Myers | 9-3 | Greenfield |
| 1976 | Mishawaka Marian | Jasper | 34- 7 | Mike Hecklinski | 12-0 | Jerry Brewer | 12-1 | Mishawaka |
| 1977 | Plymouth | Jasper | 21-14†† | Bill Nixon | 13-0 | Jerry Brewer | 12-1 | Warren Central |
| 1978 | Goshen | Brownsburg | 9- 0 | Ken Mirer | 12-1 | Vic Overman | 11-2 | Warren Central |
| 1979 | Blackford | Noblesville | 24-22 | Charles Lori | 13-0 | Jim Belden | 12-1 | Warren Central |
| 1980 | Franklin Central | NorthWood | 19-13 | Chuck Stephens | 13-0 | James Andrews | 11-2 | Warren Central |
| 1981 | Franklin Central | Goshen | 34-20 | Chuck Stephens | 12-1 | Ken Mirer | 11-1 | Warren Central |
| 1982 | Franklin Central | McCutcheon | 40-13 | Chuck Stephens | 12-2 | Frank O’Shea | 13-1 | Warren Central |
| 1983 | Indianapolis Chatard | Fort Wayne Luers | 20-16 | Chuck Schwanekamp | 14-0 | Steve Keefer | 9-5 | Lawrence Central |
| 1984 | Indianapolis Chatard | West Lafayette | 35- 7 | Chuck Schwanekamp | 13-1 | Ernie Beck | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1985 | Fort Wayne Luers | Lawrenceburg | 25- 7 | Steve Keefer | 11-3 | John Glenn Crocker | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1986 | Whitko | Tell City | 26- 0 | Bryan Sprunger | 14-0 | Mike Spencer | 10-4 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1987 | Rochester | Indianapolis Ritter | 23-20 | Mark Miller | 12-2 | Rick Carrico | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1988 | Western Boone | South Spencer | 14- 7 | Jeff Pearson | 13-1 | Jerry Denstorff | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1989 | Fort Wayne Luers | Tri-West | 24-22 | Matt Lindsay | 12-2 | Mike Gillin | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1990 | Indianapolis Scecina | River Forest | 28-27 | Ott Hurrle | 9-5 | Tom Redman | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1991 | Indianapolis Scecina | Fort Wayne Luers | 20-17 | Ott Hurrle | 11-3 | Matt Lindsay | 8-6 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1992 | Fort Wayne Luers | Westfield | 17- 0 | Matt Lindsay | 13-1 | Dick Parker | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1993 | West Lafayette | Providence | 22- 7 | Ernie Beck | 14-0 | Gene Sartini | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1994 | Bremen | Evansville Mater Dei | 38-10 | Martin Huber | 12-2 | Frank Will | 11-3 | RCA Dome |
| 1995 | North Montgomery | Bremen | 20-17 | Charley German | 13-1 | Martin Huber | 12-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1996 | North Montgomery | Fort Wayne Luers | 37-34 | Charley German | 13-1 | Matt Lindsay | 8-6 | RCA Dome |
| 1997 | Jimtown | Clarksville | 63- 0 | Bill Sharpe | 15-0 | Dennis Hawkins | 10-4 | RCA Dome |
| 1998 | Jimtown | Western Boone | 28- 0 | Bill Sharpe | 15-0 | Jeff Pearson | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1999 | Fort Wayne Luers | Danville | 38- 6 | Matt Lindsay | 13-2 | Bob Copeland | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2000 | Evansville Mater Dei | Fort Wayne Luers | 56-10 | Mike Goebel | 15-0 | Matt Lindsay | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2001 | Fort Wayne Luers | Evansville Mater Dei | 57-29 | Matt Lindsay | 14-0 | Mike Goebel | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2002 | Fort Wayne Luers | Southridge | 36-30 | Matt Lindsay | 12-3 | Brad Hanner | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2003 | Tri-West | Harding | 41-36 | Mark Haste | 14-1 | Sherwood Haydock | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2004 | Tri-West | Eastbrook | 62-21 | Mark Haste | 15-0 | Jeff Adamson | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2005 | Jimtown | North Posey | 35- 7 | Bill Sharpe | 14-1 | Joe Gengelbach | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2006 | Harding | Southridge | 20- 7 | Sherwood Haydock | 12-3 | Kelly Murphy | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2007 | Fort Wayne Luers | Heritage Christian | 21- 6 | Matt Lindsay | 11-4 | Ron Qualls | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2008 | Heritage Christian | Lewis Cass | 17-14 | Ron Qualls | 14-1 | Scott Mannering | 13-2 | Lucas Oil Stadium |
| Class 1A | ||||||||
| Year | Champion | Runner-up | Score | Winning coach | W-L | Runner-up coach | W-L | Location |
| 1973 | Mishawaka Marian | Providence | 21-14 | Mike Hecklinski | 10-2 | Gene Sartini | 11-1 | Providence |
| 1974 | Garrett | North Knox | 20- 6 | David Wiant | 11-0 | Jim Beery | 9-3 | Garrett |
| 1975 | Lawrenceburg | Wes-Del | 28-14 | Dick Meador | 11-1 | Dave Land | 11-1 | Lawrenceburg |
| 1976 | Lafayette Central Catholic | Lawrenceburg | 8- 6 | Paul LaRocca | 11-2 | Dick Meador | 11-2 | Lafayette |
| 1977 | Indianapolis Ritter | Tippecanoe Valley | 15- 6 | Duffy Hagist | 11-1 | Charles Smith | 12-1 | Lawrence Central |
| 1978 | Lawrenceburg | Fountain Central | 34- 6 | Dick Meador | 13-0 | Dale Hummer | 11-2 | Lawrence Central |
| 1979 | Tippecanoe Valley | Hamilton Southeastern | 44-14 | Charles Smith | 13-0 | David Enright | 12-1 | Lawrence Central |
| 1980 | Sheridan | North Judson | 27- 0 | Larry Wright | 13-0 | Russ Radtke | 12-1 | Lawrence Central |
| 1981 | Hamilton Southeastern | Woodlan | 7- 6 | Dave Enright | 11-0 | Leland Etzler | 8-3 | Lawrence Central |
| 1982 | Oak Hill | Southridge | 14- 7 | Terry Lichtenberg | 13-1 | Bob Hawkins | 11-3 | Lawrence Central |
| 1983 | Fountain Central | Churubusco | 12- 3 | Rick Malone | 13-1 | Rick Lightfoot | 11-3 | Lawrence North |
| 1984 | Sheridan | North Judson | 19-10 | Larry Wright | 14-0 | Russ Radtke | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1985 | Eastern Hancock | Jimtown | 20- 7 | Bob Copeland | 13-1 | Bill Sharpe | 11-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1986 | South Putnam | North Judson | 29-21 | Mark Wildman | 11-3 | Russ Radtke | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1987 | Sheridan | Jimtown | 10- 0 | Larry Wright | 12-2 | Bill Sharpe | 12-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1988 | Sheridan | Bremen | 59- 0 | Larry Wright | 14-0 | Martin Huber | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1989 | Bremen | Springs Valley | 31- 8 | John Kucela | 11-3 | Bill Harris | 13-1 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1990 | South Decatur | Southwood | 44-15 | Ken Wendling | 13-0 | David Wilhelm | 12-2 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1991 | Jimtown | Indianapolis Ritter | 13- 7 | Bill Sharpe | 12-1 | Vince Lorenzano | 9-5 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1992 | Sheridan | Indianapolis Ritter | 6- 0 | Larry Wright | 10-4 | Vince Lorenzano | 8-6 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1993 | North Miami | West Washington | 37-16 | Bob Bridge | 11-3 | Todd Pritchett | 11-3 | Hoosier Dome |
| 1994 | North White | Sheridan | 34- 7 | Jim Davis | 14-0 | Larry Wright | 11-3 | RCA Dome |
| 1995 | Carroll (Flora) | Tri-West | 26-13 | John Hendryx | 13-1 | Mark Haste | 12-2 | RCA Dome |
| 1996 | Tri-West | Carroll (Flora) | 37-14 | Mark Haste | 14-0 | John Hendryx | 13-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1997 | Pioneer | Knightstown | 49-21 | Mike Johnson | 15-0 | Don Willard | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 1998 | Sheridan | North White | 56-33 | Larry Wright | 14-1 | Jim Davis | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 1999 | Lafayette Central Catholic | Perry Central | 59- 7 | Scott Muncy | 14-0 | Terry Wagner | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2000 | Adams Central | Attica | 29-21 | Rick Minnich | 12-3 | David McDonald | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2001 | Southern Wells | Perry Central | 30- 7 | Mark Lefebvre | 14-1 | Mike Spencer | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2002 | Southwood | South Putnam | 17-14 | Terry Siddall | 13-1 | Mark Wildman | 12-3 | RCA Dome |
| 2003 | Indianapolis Ritter | Seeger | 28- 0 | Jim Boswell | 12-2 | Brian Moore | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2004 | Seeger | Indianapolis Ritter | 20- 7 | Brian Moore | 15-0 | Jim Boswell | 10-5 | RCA Dome |
| 2005 | Sheridan | Knightstown | 21- 7 | Larry Wright | 13-2 | Don Willard | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2006 | Sheridan | Indianapolis Ritter | 34-28† | Larry Wright | 15-0 | Ty Hunt | 13-2 | RCA Dome |
| 2007 | Sheridan | Rockville | 34-28 | Larry Wright | 15-0 | Herb King | 14-1 | RCA Dome |
| 2008 | Indianapolis Ritter | Sheridan | 34-27 | Ty Hunt | 15-0 | Larry Wright | 13-2 | Lucas Oil Stadium |
| †overtime | ||||||||